Zoho Creator-

SIGNAL Manuscript Review Form

Reviewer Name *

Reviewer Email: *

Title of Manuscript *

Please respond to the article in terms of its usefulness for our readers and the quality of the writing; include any other information or insight that may be helpful in evaluating the submission. Please write your review using a word processing program and then paste it into the box below.

Reviewer's Comments *

Reviewer's Recommendation *

Accept (only minor revisions needed, if any)
Conditionally Accept (editors should make revisions with the author’s consent; manuscript will not be returned)
Revise and Resubmit (the manuscript should be returned to the author for substantial revisions and resubmitted)
Reject (even if revised, the manuscript is inappropriate because of style, audience, topic or focus)

Reviewer’s comments for the writer
(Complete only if manuscript should be returned.)

In the space below, please provide specific constructive comments for the writer. Please write your comments in a word processing program and then paste them into the box below. Your comments will remain anonymous unless you ask that your name be given.

Reviewer's Comments for the Writer

Verification Code


(enter the characters you see in the above picture)